Industry, government weigh in on COTS upscreening issue

By J.R. Wilson

OXNARD, Calif. — One of the more controversial topics among engineers and program managers today is microcircuit upscreening. This involves testing a commercially manufactured microcircuit and declaring it acceptable for use in temperatures and other environments beyond its design parameters.

Central to the debate are the results of a study for the Defense Standardization Program Office (DSPO) at Fort Belvoir, Va. The study determined that upscreening is commonplace in commercial and military aircraft, as well as in weapons systems and platforms. This is despite the opposition to upscreening by members of the Semiconductor Industry Association, individual IC manufacturers, and nearly all end user commands.

The Naval Surface Warfare Center [NSWC] strongly "recommends `never allow uprating/upscreening`," reports Joe Chapman, a microcircuits consultant involved in the study.

The DSPO study has involved interviews with more than 50 companies, agencies, and individuals. Those interviewed include officials of prime contractors Lockheed Martin, GTE, Boeing, Honeywell, Raytheon, and Allied-Signal; government organizations NSWC Crane, Ind., NSWC Port Hueneme, Calif., Naval Air Systems Command, Defense Supply Center Columbus, and the Defense Microelectronics Activity; semiconductor companies and distributors Integra Technologies, Analog Devices, Arrow-Zeus, Texas Instruments, Lansdale Semiconductor, Harris Corp. (now Intersil), Xilinx, National Semiconductor, and Rochester Electronics; as well as electronics suppliers DY 4, Bell Technologies, Philips, and QP Labs.

Interviews show that contractors have procedures in place that permit the use of commercial-off-the-shelf (COTS) and upscreened components in systems and subsystems, even as concern for the process grows in the user community.

Chapman, who had a long career at the military products group of Texas Instruments Semiconductor division, says the upscreening poses several dangers. These include handling damage, non-repeatable lot manufacturing, unreliability at broad temperature ranges, a lack of traceability, and hidden costs.

"Recognition that upscreened components should be the last choice is well documented," he says. "Industry must proactively deal with the risk and the best known engineering practices must be rigidly observed."

Gorky Chin, vice president-advanced technology for Vista Controls Corp. in Santa Clarita, Calif., says an upscreened commercial integrated circuit (IC) usually is just as expensive as the original mil-spec item — and when done without the original manufacturer`s consent or approval, also can be a risky process.

That risk is twofold — the legal implications to the contractor in the event of failure, and the influence of that failure for the end user.

Despite these considerations, contractors turn to upscreened microcircuits because parts manufactured to wide temperature ranges are expensive and difficult to find. Where IC design limits used to be -60 to 130 degrees Celsius, they now tend to fall into a -10 to 80 C range, with normal operating specification limits of zero to 70 C. The full-military temperature range is -55 to 125 C.

"Computer, consumer, and much of the communications market are not concerned about performance beyond zero to 70 C nor moisture or temperature cycle effects," says Jack Stradley, central and southwest regional manager for Rochester Electronics of Newburyport, Mass. "They are obsessed with cost and performance related to data throughput. If an extra capability impacts cost, it may disappear."

Even so, upscreening/uprating "always degrades reliability," he claims. "Typical upgrading insertion causes 0.5 percent fallout for ESD/EOS," Stradley warns about the increased number of parts that fail due to handling during the upscreening process, "plus unknown ESD walking wounded."

life cycle perspective

Easily post a comment below using your Linkedin, Twitter, Google or Facebook account.

The Innovation That Matters™ Quiz

Innovation is one of the key drivers in the Defense industry. View this short video of Leon Woo, VP of Engineering at Mercury Systems, on the role of innovation. Then, answer 3 simple questions correctly to be entered into a drawing to win an Eddie Bauer fleece jacket!


Military & Aerospace Photos

Related Products

RR2P Removable Canister RAID System

Transportable data storage for mobile field use aboard planes, ships and ground transport. 2U, du...

API DC Link Power Film Capacitors

High reliability DC link capacitors for power inverter applications which require superior life e...

XPort9200 Conduction- or Air-Cooled 12-Channel High-Speed CAN Bus XMC or PMC

The XPort9200 is a conduction- or air-cooled 12-channel CAN bus XMC or PMC module. Each high-spee...

Related Companies

Winchester Systems Inc

At its founding in 1981, Winchester Systems introduced its first 5 MB disk system for Intel development system users....

API Technologies Corp

Who We Are API Technologies is a dominant technology provider of RF/microwave, microelectronics, and security technol...

Extreme Engineering Solutions Inc (X-ES)

 Extreme Engineering Solutions, Inc. (X-ES) is a leader in the design, manufacture, and support of standard and ...
Wire News provided by   

Most Popular Articles


Meeting the Gen3 backplane challenge with OpenVPX and COTS

Tight Pentagon budgets mean military systems must stay in the field for longer than ever before. This doesn't mean obsolete technology, however. Today's military electronics are being upgraded constantly, an...
Sponsored by:

Digital signal processing for signals intelligence and electronic warfare

Military & Aerospace Electronics presents an expert Webcast on the design considerations for blending general-purposes processors (GPUs), general-purpose graphics processors (GPGPUs), field-programmable ...
Sponsored by:

Advantages of Intel Architecture Products and Wind River Solutions in Military & Aerospace Applications

This webinar explains the individual advantages of the Intel Architecture hardware, available for long-life supply, and the WRS software portfolio.  There are extraordinary advantages of combining such ...
Sponsored by:

social activity

All Access Sponsors

Mil & Aero Magazine

February 2014
Volume 25, Issue 2

Download Our Apps




Follow Us On...


Military & Aerospace Electronics

Weekly newsletter covering technical content, breaking news and product information

Defense Executive

Monthly newsletter covering business news and strategic insights for executive managers

Embedded Computing Report

Monthly newsletter covering news on embedded computing in aerospace, defense and industrial-rugged applications

Unmanned Vehicles

Monthly newsletter covering news updates for designers of unmanned vehicles