Tin-lead components alive and well in the military sector

By Chris Reynolds

Editor’s note: This article is a response to a story in the July 2007 issue of Military & Aerospace Electronics entitled “RoHS one year later: supplies of leaded solder drying up,” by Keith Gurnett and Tom Adams.

Contrary to popular opinion, tin-lead termination devices are alive and well, and many devices are readily available from stock. Recently articles have been published that have stated incorrectly that passive components with tin-lead terminations are either not available or will soon become “extinct.” There are reasons for this, and there is some logic behind it, but this is a very significant overstatement.

Despite the perception that the European Restriction of Hazardous Substances (RoHS) has overwhelmed component supply and production assembly technology, today in North and South America more than 79 percent of the solder used is still tin-lead, according to the IPC Solder Quarterly Survey, 2nd Quarter 2007 (www.ipc.org).

In the case of multilayer ceramic capacitors (MLCCs), for example, many of the manufacturers in the world no longer produce parts with tin-lead terminations. This market is dominated by Japanese manufacturers who had already engaged in “lead-free” for their domestic customer base significantly in advance of RoHS.

These suppliers maintain little presence in the worldwide defense industry, however, so today many U.S. suppliers continue to provide tin-lead parts. In other words, despite the overall perception, there is almost no change in defense applications.

The same is true in many other product areas, where Far East manufacturers represent far larger market shares of the global market than they do—or ever have—in the defense and aerospace business. So the scaremongering taking place regarding RoHS dominance and the lack of availability needs to be placed in context and corrected to ensure that perception matches reality. Many manufacturers, and particularly AVX Corp. in Myrtle Beach, Calif., are working hard to ensure that customers who require the more robust and reliable terminations that incorporate lead have a stable and long-term source of supply.

Let’s take a more detailed look at the component-level evolution of “lead-free.” The compliance date for RoHS in Europe was 1 July 2006. All products encompassed by this directive that were on the shelf in EU countries by that date were mandated to contain less than 1000 parts per million (ppm) of five materials (lead, mercury, hexavalent chromium, polybrominated diphenyl ether, and polybrominated biphenyl) and less than 100 ppm of cadmium. To meet this deadline, RoHS-compliant product had to be shipping well before this date.

In the early stages of RoHS evolution, it was recognized that, if all individual components and processes were RoHS compliant, any complex system manufactured with these components and processes would necessarily be RoHS compliant.

Similarly, a component would be RoHS compliant if each individual constituent of that component were RoHS compliant—thus was born the concept of homogenous materials. Although the RoHS directive does not completely define a homogenous material, it does refer to materials that can’t be mechanically disjointed and gives guidance by example—citing a standard IC package—composed of elements including silicon die, gold contact plating, leadframes, wires, etc. The intent is that each of these constituent materials be RoHS compliant in themselves.

By analogy, the homogenous materials of an MLCC would include the dielectric body, electrodes, internal termination, and external plating. For some passive families, ensuring compliance to all six RoHS materials required several changes. Using MLCC as an example, the internal termination material could originally contain traces of cadmium. Although the internal termination material represents only a small fraction of the overall component mass, the termination cadmium content could exceed the low 100 ppm limit, and alternative materials are now used.

In other cases, the dielectric itself could contain traces of lead exceeding the RoHS limit. In the case of some class 1 dielectrics, this is a necessary part of the formulation required to maintain their electrical properties, and is exempt under annex 7 of the directive.

Needless to say, efforts by manufacturers to make passive components RoHS compliant have been huge and largely invisible. They had also, in the most part, been completed several years prior to the RoHS deadline. I say “largely invisible”—but this is really in reference to the “RoHS Five” materials—a term now used for everything excluding lead. In the case of lead content, the situation is just the reverse.

For most military and avionics users, any “fix” to a system that “ain’t broke” is a concern, so changes to the long established tin-lead soldering systems are consequently under close scrutiny.

A solder joint comprises a bond between the printed circuit board (pcb) metallization and component termination using a reflow or wave solder medium. While tin-lead can still be maintained for PCB metallization and reflow/wave, one area of concern is how to source tin-lead plated parts when the commercial trend is to lead-free, so this is a good time to review the history of component plating and review the component level tin-lead options that remain available.

Lead-Free is just one aspect of RoHS, but the general trend to “lead-free” or “green” systems predates the RoHS directive by many years. Many Japanese OEMs pioneered the technology in their systems, and as a result most Japanese active and passive component suppliers adopted lead-free terminations.

For high-cost actives, such as integrated circuits with complex leadframe structures, lead-free can include several exotic plating materials. For low-cost, high-volume passives, the common denominator for lead-free was matte tin plating—equally applicable to simple leadframe designs (tantalum chip) and overplated chips (MLCC, resistors etc.).

Another advantage is that matte tin is forward and reverse compatible—it provides a solderable surface that could be used in traditional tin-lead systems or any number of the emerging SAC (tin/silver/copper) reflow formulations or tin copper wave solder systems. When it came to adopting lead-free terminations for RoHS compliance, this was technically straightforward and for many component manufacturers already in place.

Logistically, when it came to implementation, there were several variations on a theme. For mil-spec parts, termination material composition was part of the specification, so tin-lead solder plating was maintained. This also applied to so-called COTSplus parts—“commercial off-the-shelf” parts rated with high-reliability screening.

For commercial passives, most specifications did not specify termination material composition as long as solderable surfaces were maintained—meaning that commercial parts could range from 100 percent lead to 100 percent tin.

There was no “magic switch” to convert a large number of commercial parts, so lines were converted by phasing in new external plating by case size, rating, or dielectric type depending on manufacturing setup. Dates for the completion of the conversion process were listed for all products. As the parts were interchangeable in tin-lead or lead-free systems, this meant that volume manufacturers could get ahead of the curve without requiring changes to their extensive bills of materials.

At the front end of the conversion, several users required matte tin plated parts preferentially for builds for “green” systems well before the RoHS cut-in date, so special part numbers were created for tin plating for those users in advance of full conversion. Similarly, at the back end, there were many military and aerospace users of commercial products who wanted to retain tin-lead, and now special part numbers are available for tin-lead versions of commercial passives.

Although many suppliers posted their plans for commercial parts at the time, they were often overlooked by military and aerospace users. The dialog surrounding the advent of RoHS served to raise awareness, but long after many passive conversion plans were completed.

The new challenge was for passive manufacturers to reverse-engineer many of their new products and offer tin-lead plating options. Often a part number can include a field to designate a termination finish option, but in many cases, AVX has created new series designations to completely differentiate the two types. The company did this because truncation can occur in long part number fields as bills of material are exchanged between different systems; a critical designator at the end of the part number can be lost. Establishing a new series designator at the front of the part number means that there is less chance of confusing termination types.

This aspect has become very important; one other facet of RoHS implementation was a vast amount of data exchange—suppliers are required to provide detailed MDS (Materials Data Sheets) with full ppm information on all content by part type for customers to collate into a materials compliance listing for a finished system. The terabytes of information thus generated represents a large investment by supplier and user alike, and the need to keep lead content out of RoHS products requires continuous monitoring of all base materials used.

Likewise, for tin-lead military and aerospace applications, maintaining a minimum lead content is also under close scrutiny. For the manufacturer, this means that the tin and tin-lead plating processes must be completely separated, which can influence the cost of a commercial part with tin-lead plating given the relatively low volume of the tin-lead production.

In practice, however, both systems are robust to the occasional hiccup. It would take many non-RoHS components to render a system non-compliant if the ppm content were assessed at a system level. Likewise, there is no major issue with using matte tin-plated parts in tin-lead military and aerospace systems.

The majority of high-volume passives have been matte tin terminated now for 10 to 15 years. This represents trillions of solder joints between matte tin plating in tin-lead solder. One concern has been the possibility of tin whiskers, but in practice these surfaces will be alloyed into the reflow or wave media, and they will have the benefit of additional annealing by the solder temperature.

The delineation between tin and tin-lead is here to stay, at least in the short term.

AVX has tested the performance of matte tin terminations in tin-lead and a variety of tin/silver/copper (SAC) and tin-copper systems. Wetting force and wetting time show that most SAC formulations perform well but tin-lead does have the better overall characteristic.

Experts at the U.S. Defense Supply Center Columbus (DSCC) in Columbus, Ohio, are also evaluating long-term joint reliability with SAC systems with good results. However, while military and COTSplus parts remain available with tin-lead plating as standard, and new families of tin-lead-plated commercial products are introduced, tin-lead solder processing looks set to stay in place for mission-critical operations for some years.

Chris Reynolds is product manager at AVX Corp. in Myrtle Beach, S.C. Visit AVX online at www.avxcorp.com.

Get All the Military Aerospace Electronics News Delivered to Your Inbox or Your Mailbox

Subscribe to Military Aerospace Electronics Magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest information on:

  • C4ISR
  • Cyber Security
  • Embedded Computing
  • Unmanned Vehicles

Get All the Military Aerospace Electronics News Delivered to Your Inbox or Your Mailbox

Subscribe to Military Aerospace Electronics Magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest information on:

  • C4ISR
  • Cyber Security
  • Embedded Computing
  • Unmanned Vehicles

Military & Aerospace Photos

Most Popular Articles

Related Products

XPedite7574 | 5th Generation Intel® Core™ i7 Broadwell-H Processor-Based Conduction- or Air-Cooled 3U VPX-REDI Module

The XPedite7574 is a high-performance, 3U VPX-REDI, single board computer based on the 5th genera...

XCalibur5090 | Dual Virtex-7 Based Digital Signal Processing 6U LRM FPGA with Quad 2500 MSPS DAC and 3200 MSPS ADC

The XCalibur5090 is a high-performance, reconfigurable, conduction-cooled 6U LRM module based on ...

XCalibur1645 | Freescale Eight-Core P4080 Processor-Based Conduction-Cooled 6U VPX Module

The XCalibur1645 is a high-performance, 6U VPX, single board computer supporting Freescale QorIQ ...

ScanFaker Radar Stimulation Board

The versatile ScanFaker Radar Display Stimulator Card can interface to virtually any radar displa...

PowerDNA-PPC5 Cube

5-layer, 100Base-T I/O, Data Acquisition and Control Cube with PowerPC CPU and SD slot. Has slots...


Four-Slot, Military Style I/O Chassis with Military/Rugged 38999 connectivity, 100% COTS solution...


Half-width 3U Gigabit Ethernet Data Acquisition and control chassis allows the installation of up...

PCI Board PD2-AO-16/16

Is a 16-channel, 16-bit, 100 kS/s per channel PCI analog output board for PCI bus including 16 an...

FLATRACK™ Ethernet I/O DAQ Platform

FLATRACK™ Ethernet I/O DAQ Platform accommodates installation of up to four I/O boards, completes...

PowerDNR-MIL Rack

12- slot, Military style I/O rack with Military/Rugged 38999 connectivity, 100% COTS solution, su...

Related Companies

LiquidCool Solutions

LiquidCool Solutions is a technology development firm with patents surrounding cooling electronics by total immersion...


Is a mechanical engineering consulting company headquartered in Los Angeles, CA with operations in Billerica, MA, pro...

Dspnor AS

Offers radar signal processing and distribution. The products interface to virtually any radar system in use today. T...

Curtiss-Wright Defense Solutions

About Curtiss-Wright Defense Solutions Curtiss-Wright Defense Solutions (CWDS) is a long established techno...

Southwest Antennas

Southwest Antennas designs and manufactures high-performance RF & Microwave antennas and accessories designed for tod...

Innovative Integration

  Since 1988, Innovative Integration has grown to become one of the world's leading suppliers of DSP and data ac...

CORWIL Technology Corp

CORWIL Technology, the premier US based, IC assembly and test services subcontractor, offering full back-end assembly...

Master Bond

For over 35 years, Master Bond has been supplying aerospace and defense manufacturers with custom formulated compound...

United Electronic Industries Inc

UEI is a leader in the PC/Ethernet data acquisition and control, Data Logger/Recorder and Programmable Automation Con...


IndustryARC primarily focuses on Cutting Edge Technologies and Newer Applications of the Market. Our Custom Research ...


Harsh Environment Protection for Advanced Electronics and Components

This webinar will offer an opportunity to learn more about ultra-thin Parylene conformal coatings – how they are applied, applications they protect today, and the properties and benefits they offer, includin...

New Design Tools That Help You Develop Radar That Sees the Un-seeable and Detects the Undetectable

Xilinx EW/ISR System Architect, Luke Miller, has new tricks and he’s going to tell you all about them in a new Xilinx Webinar—for free. His Webinar will cover new ways to implement Radar functions including ...
Sponsored by:

Press Releases


Curtiss-Wright Corporation today announced that its Defense Solutions division has received a contract from Sierra Nevada Corporation (SNC) to supply its small form factor ...

Innovative Integration Announces the FMC-Servo

Camarillo, CA June 19, 2015, Innovative Integration, a trusted supplier of signal processing and data acquisition hardware and software solutions, today announced the FMC-S...


Curtiss-Wright Corporation today announced that its Defense Solutions division has further enhanced its innovative VRD1 high definition (HD) video management system (VMS) w...

All Access Sponsors

Mil & Aero Magazine

August 2015
Volume 26, Issue 8

Download Our Apps




Follow Us On...


Military & Aerospace Electronics

Weekly newsletter covering technical content, breaking news and product information

Cyber Security

Monthly newsletter covering cyber warfare, cyber security, information warfare, and information security technologies, products, contracts, and procurement opportunities

Defense Executive

Monthly newsletter covering business news and strategic insights for executive managers

Electronic Warfare

Quarterly newsletter covering technologies and applications in electronic warfare, cyber warfare, optical warfare, and spectrum warfare.

Embedded Computing Report

Monthly newsletter covering news on embedded computing in aerospace, defense and industrial-rugged applications

Unmanned Vehicles

Monthly newsletter covering news updates for designers of unmanned vehicles