DOD officials eye scrapping mandate to use Ada programming

By John Keller

WASHINGTON - A decade-long fight over software languages that has raged between military and aerospace electronics designers and policy makers in the Pentagon may be coming to an end.

The Defense Department`s chief of computers, Emmett Paige Jr., is recommending a rescission of the DOD`s mandate to use the Ada programming language for real-time, mission-critical weapons and information systems.

It is not clear who in the Pentagon would need to approve Paige`s recommendation for the policy rescission to be successfully carried out, but DOD spokeswoman Susan Hansen says the policy change will probably come soon.

Some in the defense electronics industry are already applauding Paige`s move. "It`s about time," says Duncan Young, director of marketing for DY 4 Systems Inc. of Kanata, Ontario, a supplier of rugged VME single-board computers for armored vehicles, aircraft, and other military systems.

Jerry Rudisin, vice president of marketing for Rational Software Corp. of Santa Clara, Calif., says the upcoming policy shift could benefit Ada by reducing some of the hostility that many software engineers feel for the language because of its mandated nature.

Based on NRC report

Paige, the DOD`s assistant secretary for command, control, communications, computers, and intelligence, is recommending that DOD leaders adopt suggestions set forth by a committee of the National Research Council in a November report.

The report, entitled "Ada and Beyond: Software Policies for the Department of Defense," recommends that DOD spend $15 million each year to keep Ada current for its primary task - $11.5 million for support contracts and $3.5 million for in-house support. The report also recommends that military project leaders prepare a software-engineering evaluation to justify the choices of programming languages.

Paige says he believes industry engineers will be more likely to accept the benefits of using Ada if DOD leaders recommend, not require, the language. Software engineers, who would rather choose a language based on its merits rather than because of a governmental mandate, historically have resisted the Ada mandate on principle.

"His [Paige`s] belief is the mandate requiring the use of Ada should be dropped," Hansen confirms. "We will support Ada as the preferred language for weapons and for command, control, communications, computers, intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance. He says this will take the contentious points of resentment out of the DOD software process, that we will get the desired result without a mandate."

Paige has announced his retirement from DOD as soon as Pentagon leaders can find a suitable replacement.

Mandate problems

Chief complaints about Ada since it first became a military-wide standard in 1983 centered on the perception among industry software engineers that DOD officials were "shoving Ada down our throats."

Ada, which over its lifetime has had backing from the U.S. military, the American National Standards Institute, and the International Standards Organization, was designed to enforce methodical software engineering practices, ease the periodic update of program code, and reduce the number of programming languages used for military systems.

Ada, particularly with its new Ada 95 extensions and object-oriented approach, is often judged to be superior to C and C++, its two chief rivals for the software engineer`s affection, for its reliability, maintainability, and ability to handle real-time tasks.

While DOD Ada enforcement has always been lackluster and spotty, many in industry interpreted the policy from former Defense Secretary William Perry to use commercial-off-the-shelf (COTS) equipment whenever possible as wholesale license to scrap Ada programs.

It is not clear yet if industry leaders will alter their Ada programs, but indications are already emerging that some microprocessor manufacturers may not even spend the money necessary to secure Ada software support for new generations of devices.

Ada proponents and antagonists alike, however, say the time may be right to eliminate the Ada mandate, which many claim never received enthusiastic enforcement from DOD. Systems designers always had a relatively easy time either securing waivers from the mandate, or simply using another language without seeking approval to do so.

Business as usual?

"Removing the mandate is a nonsequitur. We haven`t had an enforced mandate, so removing something that has not been enforced is a zero proposal," says longtime Ada champion Ralph Crafts, vice president of sales and marketing at Ada vendor OC Systems Inc. in Fairfax, Va.

"The mandate has always had a very large `out,` if you will, to let you use something other than Ada, based on good software engineering considerations," Crafts continues. "This new approach, if implemented, is a restatement of what the old policy really was, that Ada was the default choice unless there was evidence that something else was better.

"Now you still have to go through a software-engineering evaluation and choose the language that best meets the engineering of DOD software systems," Crafts says. "So Ada should be the language, since it was designed for good software engineering. Nothing really is going to change."

Still, Crafts and other Ada proponents say Paige`s decision to drop the Ada mandate is a mistake, and could come back to haunt DOD officials in the future.

"It is a mistake not to have a strong DOD language policy," Crafts says. "The fact of the matter is there is no other language better suited for accomplishing the defense mission than Ada. The whole reason for Ada was to eliminate the need to support hundreds of different languages and dialects. As we do away with a single language policy, if we don`t have something strong, we are reverting back to the software anarchy of the `70s, and we are starting down that path now."


Easily post a comment below using your Linkedin, Twitter, Google or Facebook account.


Most Popular Articles

Related Products

SBC-K7 Embedded PC for Instrumentation and Control

The SBC-K7 is an ideal platform for embedded instrumentation that combines an Atom PC running Win...

Rugged Mobile Communications Server

Advanced communications server designed to be deployed in environments where it needs to meet cer...

RR2P Removable Canister RAID System

Transportable data storage for mobile field use aboard planes, ships and ground transport. 2U, du...

Sensors Unlimited GA1280JSX High Resolution, Mil-Rugged, Extended High Sensitivity InGaAs SWIR Camera

Manufactures a high resolution, mil-rugged, extended high-sensitivity 0.9 Mpixel InGaAs SWIR came...

M1U20xx 1U Military-Grade Computer System

The M1U20xx Military-Grade Rack Mount System is a reliable high-performance mil-spec 1U solution ...

TFX-19 Trifold Rackmount LCD

The TFX1-19 is a rugged military grade high performance 2U rackmount LCD panel display offering t...

P317xx Portable Computer System w/ Three 17" LCDs

The P317xx portable " lunchbox" system is unique in offering three 17" 1280x1024 resolution LCD d...

CCXR-17 Slideways Side Access Rackmount LCD Keyboard

The CCXR-17 is a unique Side Access space-efficient military-grade high-performance 1U rackmount ...

M4U20xx 4U Rackmount Military-Grade Computer

A 4U rugged military-grade computer offering the latest long-availability high-performance mother...

Large Fiber Collimators

Diffraction Limited Large Fiber Collimators are designed for long distance beam propagation with ...

Related Companies

Innovative Integration

  Since 1988, Innovative Integration has grown to become one of the world's leading suppliers of DSP and data ac...

Elma Electronic Inc

Who we are...   About Elma Electronic Systems   The Systems division of Elma Electronic Inc. supplies the

Winchester Systems Inc

At its founding in 1981, Winchester Systems introduced its first 5 MB disk system for Intel development system users....

Extreme Engineering Solutions Inc (X-ES)

 Extreme Engineering Solutions, Inc. (X-ES) is a leader in the design, manufacture, and support of standard and ...

American Infrared Solutions (AIRS)

American Infrared Solutions

GE Intelligent Platforms

GE Intelligent Platforms is a leading global provider of embedded computing systems and modules for a wide range of a...

Raycom Electronics

Raycom Electronics, Inc., a subsidiary of Electro Technik Industries (ETI), was incorporated in 1965.  The compa...

Trenton Systems Inc

Designs and manufactures rugged rackmount computers and MIL-STD-810 systems using both standard COTS as well as custo...

Sensors Unlimited - UTC Aerospace Systems

Manufactures near-IR (NIR) and shortwave IR (SWIR) cameras (available fully packaged or as OEM imaging modules), line...
Wire News provided by   

social activity

Webcasts

Meeting the Gen3 backplane challenge with OpenVPX and COTS

Tight Pentagon budgets mean military systems must stay in the field for longer than ever before. This doesn't mean obsolete technology, however. Today's military electronics are being upgraded constantly, an...
Sponsored by:

Digital signal processing for signals intelligence and electronic warfare

Military & Aerospace Electronics presents an expert Webcast on the design considerations for blending general-purposes processors (GPUs), general-purpose graphics processors (GPGPUs), field-programmable ...
Sponsored by:

Advantages of Intel Architecture Products and Wind River Solutions in Military & Aerospace Applications

This webinar explains the individual advantages of the Intel Architecture hardware, available for long-life supply, and the WRS software portfolio.  There are extraordinary advantages of combining such ...
Sponsored by:

All Access Sponsors

View the 2014 Buyer's Guide Now!


Mil & Aero Magazine

September 2014
Volume 25, Issue 9
file

Download Our Apps



iPhone

iPad

Android

Follow Us On...



Newsletters

Military & Aerospace Electronics

Weekly newsletter covering technical content, breaking news and product information
SUBSCRIBE

Defense Executive

Monthly newsletter covering business news and strategic insights for executive managers
SUBSCRIBE

Embedded Computing Report

Monthly newsletter covering news on embedded computing in aerospace, defense and industrial-rugged applications
SUBSCRIBE

Unmanned Vehicles

Monthly newsletter covering news updates for designers of unmanned vehicles
SUBSCRIBE