Aerospace and defense systems integrators continue their reliance on radiation-hardened electronics for space avionics

June 5, 2012
TECHNOLOGY FOCUS, 5 June 2012. Systems architects and integrators rely on radiation-hardened and radiation-tolerant innovations to ensure the extended, uninterrupted operation of electronics in space. Space is wrought with radiation, which can alter the effectiveness of, interfere with, and even render useless myriad space-based systems. As a result, systems architects and systems integrators are turning to aerospace technology firms for the latest radiation-hardened and radiation-tolerant electronics components and solutions.

TECHNOLOGY FOCUS, 5 June 2012. Systems architects and integrators rely on radiation-hardened and radiation-tolerant innovations to ensure the extended, uninterrupted operation of electronics in space.

“Space is an extremely hazardous vacuum filled with lethal radiation, storms of micrometeoroids, extreme variations of temperature, and all manner of man-made debris. Any one or a combination of these can damage or even destroy unshielded satellites and other spacecraft,” explains a representative at the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) in Washington.

Space is wrought with radiation, which can alter the effectiveness of, interfere with, and even render useless myriad space-based systems. As a result, systems architects and systems integrators are turning to aerospace technology firms for the latest radiation-hardened and radiation-tolerant electronics components and solutions.

Essential for effectiveness

“High-reliability, radiation-hardened and radiation-tolerant components are vital in aerospace and defense applications,” insists Minh Nguyen, marketing manager, Space FPGAs (field-programmable gate arrays) at Microsemi Corp. in San Jose, Calif. After all, he continues, “they contribute to the reliability of the whole system and the success of the mission.

Aerospace, defense, and commercial applications and organizations rely heavily on space-based systems, such as communications satellites, driving the need for rugged and reliable electronics. “Failure is not an option in space, due to its great impact to civilian and national security if there is an interruption in service,” Nguyen adds.

Cost and convenience are also critical factors to consider, given the difficulties associated with servicing or replacing space-based electronics. “An aerospace or defense mission is usually costly and requires the highest-quality electronics because these are systems which have to work in an environment where there is no easy way to access, debug, and repair,” Nguyen affirms.

For these and other reasons, radiation-hardened and -tolerant components are “tested and screened to survive the most rigorous radiation in the space environment and maintain their reliability throughout the life of a mission,” Nguyen says.

Space standards

Aerospace professionals are seeing more stringent demands from engineers and managers for electronics components and systems that meet the highest quality standards, such as Qualified Manufacturer List (QML) Class V—considered to be the highest qualification for space integrated circuits (ICs).

U.S. Defense Logistics Agency officials have qualified Microsemi’s RTAX-S/SL radiation-tolerant field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) under Qualified Manufacturers List (QML) Class V in accordance with military performance standard MIL-PRF-38535 space-level qualification requirements. QML Class V qualification provides designers and users of space-flight systems with an added level of assurance as to the quality and reliability of the RTAX-S/SL FPGA product family, says a representative.

The achievement marks an important milestone in the company’s history, according to Esam Elashmawi, vice president and general manager at Microsemi. "Microsemi has been providing high-reliability solutions to the aerospace market for more than five decades, and we delivered our first radiation-tolerant RTAX-S FPGA in 2004," he says.

Microsemi’s radiation-tolerant FPGAs have performed flight-critical functions in space systems orbiting around the Earth, Moon, Mars, Venus, and the Sun, as well as on missions to the surface of Mars and into the furthest reaches of the solar system, according to Nguyen.

“In many of these programs, like the Mars Science Lab and Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter, Microsemi radiation-tolerant FPGAs play a vital role in control and telemetry applications for the spacecraft, as well as mission-critical science instruments,” Nguyen says. Microsemi radiation-tolerant FPGAs are currently employed in a variety of commercial and defense space programs and applications, including telemetry tracking and control, electrical power systems, digital communication payloads, radio-frequency communications payloads, imaging payloads, and solid-state recorders.

Astronomical HPC

The proven ability to mitigate the effects of radiation is just one of the requirements aerospace engineers must consider when selecting the optimal electronics for space-based systems. Military and commercial space customers are under the same pressures: higher functionality and higher performance, while not consuming excessive power, Nguyen notes. In fact, space customers in some programs—such as low Earth orbit, tactical, and short-duration programs—require a combination of reprogrammability, functionality, and radiation tolerance for the mission.

Modern space missions are collecting a wealth of data, driving the need for increased processing power and capacity. Engineers at BAE Systems in Manassas, Va., are developing fourth-generation, radiation-hardened computers for space applications using Power Architecture technology licensed from Freescale Semiconductor in Austin, Texas. Use of Freescale’s Power Architecture processor cores is expected to increase onboard satellite processing by 10 times the current rate, enabling high-performance computing (HPC) onboard satellites and parallel multi-core processing for myriad space applications.

“The licensing arrangement enables a massive leap in our processing capability, providing our customers the ability to maximize application performance while leveraging existing infrastructure and experience,” explains Ian McDonald, director of space products and systems at BAE Systems. “Freescale’s experience with high-performance computing provides BAE Systems a technological advantage to enable mission applications that are unattainable with current generation hardware platforms.”

BAE Systems’ space-qualified computer products and application specific integrated circuits (ASICs), more than 600 of which have been placed in orbit, can now benefit from Freescale’s e5500 64-bit Power Architecture core and QorIQ platform, including CoreNet and OCeaN fabrics, memory controller, memory elements, and high-speed interfaces.

Electronics assurances

“The importance of radiation-hardened/tolerant electronics cannot be overstated; the assurance of highly reliable, qualified, and environmentally hardened devices are all key to the success of any aerospace application/program,” acknowledges Elaine Gonsalves, business development manager, Standard Products at Aeroflex in Colorado Springs, Colo. A variety of components—including microprocessors, memory, medium-scale integration (MSI) logic, ASICs, and power electronics—from Aeroflex are employed in such aerospace applications as command and data handling, FPGA boot loading, and SpaceWire routing.

The Core On-Board Computer (OBC) of a Germany University project, called the “Flying Laptop” micro satellite, uses several Aeroflex Colorado Springs Standard Products, Gonsalves reveals. “The project’s primary objectives are technology evaluation and earth observation,” she says.

The OBC uses the Aeroflex UT699 LEON 3FT SPARC V8 microprocessor, as well as the company’s static random-access memory (SRAM), RadClock and clock buffer, and several MSI logic devices. The project also employs software tools supporting the real-time executive for multiprocessor systems (RTEMS) operating system managed by OAR Corp. in Huntsville, Ala., and CCSDS IP from Aeroflex Gailser in Sweden. A flight variant of the OBC is currently undergoing integration testing, whereas the satellite is expected to launch in 2013.

SWaP in space

Designers and integrators of space-based systems are plagued by strict size, weight, and power (SWaP) requirements; yet, aerospace technology firms are partnering and innovating to help alleviate such challenges.

International Rectifier (IR), a provider of power-management technology in El Segundo, Calif., introduced its GH Series of RAD-Hard DC-DC converters to maximize efficiency for onboard spacecraft applications requiring long mission life, such as up to 15 years. GH Series devices are well suited for designs using digital signal processors and FPGAs that require a supply voltage as low as 1.0 volt, sport an internal electromagnetic interference (EMI) filter, and feature magnetically coupled feedback for robust operation in radiation environments.

“As a low output voltage, highly efficient solution, the GH Series addresses the ongoing need to reduce the overall size and weight of the system together with the increasing requirements of FPGA and other digital circuitries for increased bandwidth and data processing speed of spacecraft electronics,” says Tiva Bussarakons, marketing director for IR’s HiRel DC-DC converter products.

Powerful prospects

“A reliable, ongoing power supply is essential to a space mission’s success,” a European Space Agency (ESA) representative says. Power electronics, such as power conditioning and power conversion devices, can also help prevent harmful current surges and switch voltages.

International Rectifier power supplies are being used in low Earth orbit (LEO) and geosynchronous (GEO) satellite applications. “Radiation-hardened parts are required in most GEO satellites,” explains Michael Sullivan, director of marketing at International Rectifier. “In LEO satellites, the radiation often can move into radiation tolerance levels due to the location of the orbit and the duration of flight.

“In spacecraft, both radiation-hardened and radiation-tolerant are used,” Sullivan adds. “IR continues to develop new radiation-hardened devices for the space market as the number of satellites continues to grow both in size and in number.”

Aeroflex RAD in Colorado Springs, Colo., uses an “Intellectual Property Liberation” (IP Lib) model for delivering radiation-tolerant electronics for satellites systems, describes Joseph Benedetto, vice president, Radiation Technology at Aeroflex RAD. Aeroflex RAD partnered with Linear Technology Corp., also in Colorado Springs, to manufacture the RAD1419, a radiation-tolerant analog-to-digital (A/D) converter that uses the Linear Technology LTC1419, an A/D converter that draws 150mW from ±5-volt supplies.

“By partnering with Linear Technology and using the IP Lib model, Aeroflex RAD was able to introduce this product to the satellite community in a fraction of the time and at a fraction of the cost of traditional radiation-hardened components,” Benedetto says.

COTS considerations

Aerospace and defense organizations continue to invest in, and benefit from, commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) technologies and products.

“To reduce weight and component cost, distributed power systems are relying more on smaller, less expensive point of load (POL) converters used in conjunction with the larger, traditional, isolated DC-DC converters,” says Monty Pyle, executive director of sales at VPT, says. “We’ve been asked for a higher current option without the need to waste space and weight stringing together multiple POL converters.”

VPT Inc., part of the HEICO Electronic Technologies Group and located in Bothell, Wash., provides off-the-shelf solutions, including DC-DC power converters and EMI filters, for space applications and customers, including NASA. VPT engineers designed and manufactured the company’s SVGA0515 Series point of load DC-DC converter for use in the extreme environment of space and to save board space, weight, and cost for power systems headed for LEO, MEO (medium Earth orbit), GEO, and deep space missions.

VPT’s new, 15-amp, radiation-hardened device is the latest addition to VPT’s line of space DC-DC converters, delivers up to 50 Watts of output power, and is qualified to MIL-PRF-38534 Class H and Class K, set by the Defense Logistics Agency. SVGA0515 is “packaged in hermetically sealed metal cases for reliable power delivery through the extreme temperature, shock, vibration, and radiation environments of space travel,” reveals a representative.

Bright future

“There will continue to be a need in the Aerospace industry for rad-hard and rad-tolerant components and systems in the future,” Aeroflex Colorado Springs’ Gonsalves predicts.

Company list

3D Plus
McKinney, Texas

Aeroflex RAD
Colorado Springs, Colo.

Aitech Defense Systems
Chatsworth, Calif.

ASIC Advantage
Sunnyvale, Calif.

Altera Corp.
San Jose, Calif.

BAE Systems Electronic Solutions
Manassas, Va.

Cadence Design Systems
San Jose, Calif.

C-MAC Micro Technology
Great Yarmouth, England

Crane Interpoint
Redmond, Wash.

Cypress Semiconductor
Cypress Semiconductor San Jose, Calif.

Freescale Semiconductor
Austin, Texas

HDL Research Lab
Brenham Texas

Honeywell Microelectronics and Precision Sensors
Plymouth, Minn.

International Rectifier
El Segundo, Calif.

Intersil Corp.
Milpitas, Calif.

Linear Technology Corp.
Milpitas, Calif.

Maxwell Technologies
San Diego, Calif.

Mentor Graphics
Wilsonville, Ore.

Meggitt Sensing Systems
San Juan Capistrano, Calif.

Microelectronics Research Development Corp.
Colorado Springs, Colo.

Micropac Industries
Garland, Texas

Microsemi SoC Products Group
Mountain View, Calif.

Modular Devices
Shirley, N.Y.

MS Kennedy
Liverpool, N.Y.

Northrop Grumman Aerospace Systems
Redondo Beach, Calif.

paste company name here
Peregrine Semiconductor Corp. San Diego, Calif.

Radiation Assured Devices
Colorado Springs, Colo.

Rochester Electronics
Newburyport, Mass.

Costa Mesa, Calif.

Space Micro
Discovery Bay, Calif.

paste company name here
STMicroelectronics Geneva, Switzerland

Melbourne, Fla.

Teledyne Microelectronic Technologies
Los Angeles, Calif.

Tezzaron Semiconductor
Naperville, Ill.

Texas Instruments
Dallas, Texas

Lebarge, France

Triad Semiconductor
Winston-Salem, N.C.

Ultra Communications
Vista, Calif.

Everett, Wash.

San Jose, Calif.

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Military Aerospace, create an account today!